Illinois Bankruptcy Lawyer is written by Patrick J Hart, a bankruptcy lawyer with offices in Libertyville, Illinois. For more information on bankruptcy call our office for an appointment at 847 680-7240.
Friday, November 23, 2012
When Can Mortgage Debt Forgiveness Be Tax Free
Last week we talked about the fact that as of January 1, 2013 a person, who loses their home, because he or she cannot pay their mortgage, might have to report the amount of unpaid mortgage debt as taxable income, on his or her tax return. This could prove very costly for individuals, who go through a foreclosure, dispose of their home in a short sale, or sign the title to their home over to the mortgage company in a deed in lieu of foreclosure.
This is because the general rule in the Internal Revenue Code provides that a forgiveness of debt creates taxable income unless the debtor files bankruptcy or is insolvent. When the housing market collapsed, Congress passed a temporary law to avoid the tax on mortgage indebtedness under certain circumstances, and the law is scheduled to expire at the end of 2012. Of course our lawmakers have made it a regular habit of extend tax laws about to expire at the last minute, so it is still possible, we will continue to have this relief available.
What I wanted to point out today were the requirements for avoiding tax on mortgage forgiveness under the "temporary" law. In the first place a taxpayer can only claim the relief, if the mortgage is on his or her principal residence. A person will be out of luck, in the case of a vacation home or rental property.
Furthermore, the forgiven mortgage must be home acquisition indebtedness. If a homeowner paid off the original mortgage and took out a new loan on the house to make investments, she will have to pay income tax on the debt she does not have to pay. Qualified acquisition cannot exceed $2,000,000 or $1,000,000 for a married individual filing separately. It can include mortgage indebtedness for substantial improvement of the residence. It can also include refinancing of home acquisition indebtedness provided the amount refinanced does not exceed the original acquisition debt.
Monday, November 19, 2012
Bankruptcy And Joint Child Custody
The means test is a mathematical formula that the bankruptcy law used to determine whether an individual has a low enough income to file a Chapter 7 bankruptcy rather than a Chapter 13 bankruptcy, in which he or she will have to make monthly payments to partially repay the debts. If an individual or a married couple have a high enough income to required them to file a Chapter 13 bankruptcy, the means test will also be used to calculate the amount of their monthly payments.
The means test begins with the debtors monthly income, and then subtracts out the allowable expenses which are set by the bankruptcy law, and which are not the same thing as the debtors’ actual monthly expenses. The means test is calculated by household size, and even if a person does not file a joint bankruptcy with their husband or wife, if they are living with their spouse, the husband’s or wife’s income and expenses are considered in calculating whether the debtor qualifies for Chapter 7.
The bankruptcy law is not as clear on who will be considered a dependent as the income tax law is. In fact in bankruptcy the cases do not agree, if someone needs to qualify as a dependent to be a member of the household. In some cases where divorced parents share the custody of children debtors have been allowed to combine the fraction of the time various children and step children live in their house to add up to the total number of household members that will be allowed under the means test.
The means test begins with the debtors monthly income, and then subtracts out the allowable expenses which are set by the bankruptcy law, and which are not the same thing as the debtors’ actual monthly expenses. The means test is calculated by household size, and even if a person does not file a joint bankruptcy with their husband or wife, if they are living with their spouse, the husband’s or wife’s income and expenses are considered in calculating whether the debtor qualifies for Chapter 7.
The bankruptcy law is not as clear on who will be considered a dependent as the income tax law is. In fact in bankruptcy the cases do not agree, if someone needs to qualify as a dependent to be a member of the household. In some cases where divorced parents share the custody of children debtors have been allowed to combine the fraction of the time various children and step children live in their house to add up to the total number of household members that will be allowed under the means test.
Monday, November 12, 2012
Taxation of Home Mortgage Debt Forgiveness
Home values in America have dropped substantially in the last five years, and many people, who have found their homes worth less than they owe on the mortgage, have been forced to abandon their homes in short sales, deeds in lieu of foreclosure, or court foreclosures. As a bankruptcy lawyer I have dealt with a number of people in this situation, and while losing one’s home is not a happy experience, I know that in many cases the homeowners can at least the avoid owing a deficiency to the mortgage companies, when the house sells for less than the debt.
When a homeowner shorts sells a home or grants his mortgage company title in a deed in lien of foreclosure, the agreement with the mortgage company usually calls for no additional liability once the transaction is completed. When a home is foreclosed the court can enter a deficiency judgment ordering the homeowner to pay the mortgage company the difference between the sales price on the home and the amount owed to the mortgage company, but in many cases the court does not enter this deficiency judgement, and the homeowner ends up owing nothing more.
Beginning on January 1, 2013 however, the homeowner might face an income tax liability on the amount of mortgage debt that does not get repaid in one of the above transactions. The general rule under Section 108 of the Internal Revenue Code provides that cancelled indebtedness is taxable income for the debtor. However, when the housing market collapsed, Congress passed a temporary law relieving distressed homeowners of this liability, provided the cancelled debt was the result of acquiring the house as one’s principal residence, and the acquisition indebtedness does not exceed $2,000,000 (or $1,000,000 in the case of a married individual filing separately).
Unfortunately, like with many other recently enacted provisions of the Internal Revenue Code, this law is set to expire on January 1, 2013 unless Congress takes some last minute action to salvage the relief .
Saturday, November 10, 2012
The Coming Estate Tax Increase
On January 1, 2013 the Federal estate tax exemption is scheduled to go down from $5,200,000 to $1,000,000, which means that the death tax, which has only been the a concern for the relatively wealthy will begin to impose a burden on many families, who consider themselves middle class.
This would seem to indicate that these newly affected individuals should be seeking out the services of estate planning attorneys to take advantage of the opportunities to reduce this tax. Unfortunately, the planning process is complicated by the fact that no one knows whether this tax increase is really going to take place or whether Congress at the last minute will restore part or all of the higher exemption.
Unfortunately, ever since 2001 when our lawmakers decided to phase out estate taxes over ten years, we have had to deal with having no permanent answer on what estate taxes will be. The 2001 law called for raising the $1,000,000 exemption to $3,500,000 over a number of years with the estate taxes disappearing in 2010. However, in 2011 the estate tax would resume with the exemption automatically reverting to $1,000,000. Up until the end of 2010 many people expected this would actually take place, but at the end of December Congress provided for a $5,000,000 exemption beginning in 2011. However, once again they provided that the exemption would revert to $1,000,000, this time beginning in 2013, and once again as the day of reckoning approaches we do not know what is going to happen.
This would seem to indicate that these newly affected individuals should be seeking out the services of estate planning attorneys to take advantage of the opportunities to reduce this tax. Unfortunately, the planning process is complicated by the fact that no one knows whether this tax increase is really going to take place or whether Congress at the last minute will restore part or all of the higher exemption.
Unfortunately, ever since 2001 when our lawmakers decided to phase out estate taxes over ten years, we have had to deal with having no permanent answer on what estate taxes will be. The 2001 law called for raising the $1,000,000 exemption to $3,500,000 over a number of years with the estate taxes disappearing in 2010. However, in 2011 the estate tax would resume with the exemption automatically reverting to $1,000,000. Up until the end of 2010 many people expected this would actually take place, but at the end of December Congress provided for a $5,000,000 exemption beginning in 2011. However, once again they provided that the exemption would revert to $1,000,000, this time beginning in 2013, and once again as the day of reckoning approaches we do not know what is going to happen.
Monday, November 5, 2012
Length of Chapter 13 Bankruptcy Plan
In a Chapter 13 bankruptcy an individual debtor makes payments (usually monthly) under a plan and over the plan period pays back part or all of her debt. The amount of the debt paid depends on how much income the individual has available.
The maximum period allowed by law for a Chapter 13 plan is five years or sixty months, in which the debtor usually makes sixty monthly payments and at the completion of the period the individual receives a discharge from the court. One reason Congress has set the five year limit is that anything longer looks dangerously like involuntary servitude. While some plans run for less than five years, most people filing bankruptcy have financial problems that make it necessary for them to utilize the maximum time available, and it is probably fair to say that five years is also the normal period for a Chapter 13 plan.
Based on the law the courts will not confirm a plan that requires more than five years, but the question sometimes comes up of what happens, if because of subsequent events the debtor fails to complete his payments in sixty months. Does the case automatically get dismissed? The answer is no, not necessarily.
In the first place the dismissal would not be automatic. A party in interest such as the trustee would have to bring a motion for the court to dismiss the bankruptcy, and I have seen cases where the trustee has proven willing to work with the debtor, when extenuating circumstances have arisen. Furthermore, the bankruptcy court has the discretion to allow a debtor additional time to complete the plan, and if he felt there was a reasonable cause for the delay a bankruptcy judge would not necessarily grant the motion to dismiss.
Wednesday, October 31, 2012
Disposal of Secured Property Prior to Bankruptcy
When the borrower on a secured loan against property, such as a mortgage on a home or a car loan, files bankruptcy, the debt is discharged against the property, but the security interest remains. Thus in the case of a car loan after the bankruptcy, the bank may repossess the car, if the borrower fails to make payments, but the bank may not go after the borrower for any deficiency, if they fail to sell the car for the entire amount of the loan.
The question that sometimes arises is what happens, if the borrower has disposed of secured property prior to filing bankruptcy. In the case of a house the mortgage holder could still foreclose on the house, and I suspect they would. What happens though, when a smaller item such as a television or a refrigerator is given away or thrown out before the bankruptcy. The legal answer is that the security interest stays with the property, and if you go bankrupt the retailer could trace down the computer you gave to your Aunt Millie for her birthday and demand it back. The practical answer is that with most types of property it is not worth the effort to trace the property to the new owner, and in affect the debt is discharged.
If the debt is large enough to make it worth while though, which is more likely to be the case in business bankruptcies than consumer bankruptcies, the secured creditor may have an additional remedy. Disposing of property in violation of the terms of the secured loan agreement is conversion, which is a tort. Under Federal Bankruptcy Law, if a debtor has committed a willful and malicious tort the creditor may bring an action in bankruptcy court to declare the debt nondischargeable.
Monday, October 29, 2012
Can Fraud Issue Be Raised For The First Time in Bankruptcy Court
While bankruptcy allows individuals in need of a fresh financial start to discharge many of their debts in bankruptcy, certain categories of debts are nondischargeable. Some debts are automatically not dischargeable, such as child support or criminal fines. Others types of nondischargeable debts though, such as loans obtained through fraud, place the burden of proof on the creditor to convince the bankruptcy court that he or she should be allowed to collect the debt.
Thus a bankruptcy attorney will sometimes find it necessary to defend an adversary action filed by a bank or a credit card company, seeking to hold the debt nondischargeable on the grounds of fraud. However, often by the time an individual files a bankruptcy, a creditor has already brought a lawsuit in a state court to collect the debt, and the question can arise whether he can claim fraud in his bankruptcy claim, when he never brought the matter up in the state court.
In most cases the bankruptcy courts have ruled that not having previously complained of fraud does not permanently bar pleading the grounds in a bankruptcy action. The courts realize that as a practical matter, whether fraud existed or not, the creditor has little reason to raise the issue in state court, when all he has to prove is that the money is owed, and the judges tend to believe that it would be unfair to permanently bar the creditor from raising the argument, merely because he or she failed to anticipate the subsequent bankruptcy filing.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)